Subways, Skylines, and Shark Deals: The Artist's Guide to Record Deals

abeam93
Oct 16
5 min read

In a city full of dreamers, every artist eventually meets the sharks. The key is knowing how to swim before you dive.

I couldn't help but wonder, in the ever-changing cityscape of the music industry, are record labels the sharks circling the waters... or the skyscrapers that help us see the skyline from a new height?

For years, the conversation around signing to a label has been polarized. On one block, the "stay independent" crowd preaches freedom, control, and DIY hustle. On another, artists still crave that elusive deal, the one that promises structure, strategy, and access to a bigger stage.

But maybe the real conversation isn't whether labels are good or bad. Maybe it's how we approach them. Because walking into a label meeting is a lot like stepping onto the set of Shark Tank: lights on, cameras rolling, and all eyes on you and your pitch.

Why Record Labels Still Matter

Labels are the skyscrapers of the music city, expensive real estate, but full of resources. They've got the connections, the budget, the marketing muscle, and the kind of global visibility that's hard to achieve on your own. They're not just investors; they're infrastructure.

A good label can turn your single into a statement, your tour into a movement, your vision into a visible brand. They know the streets, the shortcuts, and the skyline views. But they don't just hand over the keys; you have to earn your way in.

The Shark Tank Parallel

Every artist dreams of walking into that meeting where someone across the table says, "We want in." But just like in Shark Tank, the deal isn't made on dreams alone. It's made on leverage.

Think of yourself as the entrepreneur. The product? You. The pitch? Your art, your story, your world.

The sharks, or in this case, the A&Rs and label executives, are listening for proof that your idea works. They want to know your audience, your numbers, your momentum. They're not just buying into your sound, they're buying into your strategy.

Your Bargaining Power Is Everything

In the city, the people who get where they're going know the subway map by heart. In the industry, your map is made of data, direction, and drive.

Ask yourself:

What makes your sound stand out in a crowded skyline?
What's your mission, your "why," your compass?
Who's your demographic, and how do they move through your world?
What need are you solving for them: empowerment, escape, belonging, freedom?
And most importantly, what numbers prove your train is already in motion: streams, followers, engagement, merch sales, ticket sales?

Because when you sit across from a label, it's not about convincing them you're great. It's about showing them you've already built a city worth investing in.

The Win-Win Relationship

Not all sharks bite like Kevin O'Leary. Some partner, some mentor, some push you to grow in ways you couldn't have on your own.

The best record deals are collaborations, not cages. They're rooted in transparency, shared goals, and mutual respect. If you walk into the room knowing your worth and what kind of partnership you're looking for, the power dynamic shifts. You're no longer just hoping they'll choose you; you're evaluating whether they fit your vision, too.

Different Routes, Same City

Every artist's goals, needs, and dreams are different, and so are their routes through the city. For some, the indie label or DIY path is the perfect neighborhood: more freedom, more control, and a slower, intentional pace. For others, a major label is exactly what they need: the skyline view, the resources, and the team to amplify their vision.

Neither path is black or white, and neither is "better." It's about alignment, understanding the kind of support, structure, and creative ecosystem your art truly needs to thrive. Because whether you're riding solo or hopping on a major line, the goal is the same: to keep moving forward on your terms.

Know the Terms Before You Sign

In this city, the street signs matter, and in the music industry, so does the fine print. If you're walking into a deal, don't just bring your talent, bring your literacy. Because the biggest difference between a dream and a disaster is usually hidden in the contract clauses.

Here are the essentials every artist should know before shaking hands on a deal:

Advance: the upfront money a label gives you, but it's a loan, not a gift. It's recouped (paid back) from your share of revenue, usually starting with album sales and streaming royalties.
Recoupment: the repayment process. Before you see any profit, your royalties first go toward paying back the advance and any expenses (recording, marketing, tour support, etc.).
Cross-Collateralization: when the label pulls money from other income streams like merch, touring, or publishing to recoup that same advance. It's basically tying all your revenue sources together into one big repayment pool. Recoupment is the rule, cross-collateralization is the loophole for labels to gain their money before you do ( Best to not have a cross-collateralization clause).
Royalty Rate: the percentage you earn after recoupment. The higher your leverage, the better your cut. Typically anywhere from 10% to 22%
Deductions: labels subtract costs for marketing, packaging, piracy, and promotion before paying you. Golden rule: fewer deductions mean more money for you.
Grant of Rights: how the label gains control of your masters. They might license them (temporary) or assign them (permanent). Ideally, negotiate a short license, 3 to 5 years, and always request a reversion (when rights return to you)
Exclusivity: you can't record for another label during the deal term, and sometimes you're even restricted from re-recording your own songs afterward.
Term: how long the deal lasts. Indie deals often cover 1 to 3 albums, major labels 4 to 7 albums (though this is changing as albums are fading out and singles are coming into major play with streaming)
Territory: the geographic area where your label has rights, from one country to worldwide.

Think of these terms like subway stops, miss one and you might end up miles from where you meant to go. Never sign without legal eyes on it. Even the best shark won't bite if you swim with a good lawyer or attorney.

The Takeaway

Maybe it's time to stop seeing record labels as villains and start seeing them as skyscrapers. Tools for height, not handcuffs. In this concrete jungle, there's room for both independence and partnership; it's all about timing, leverage, and knowing the lay of your land.

So next time you're curled up watching Shark Tank, take notes. Seriously, grab a notebook and pen, and write some notes. Notice who walks in with confidence, who knows their numbers, who owns their story - and who gets swallowed whole because they didn't. The show may be about business, but the lesson's universal: whether you're pitching to investors or performing for a crowd, know your worth, know your world, and never let anyone else drive your train.

I couldn't help but wonder... maybe every artist's journey through this city isn't about avoiding the sharks or chasing the skyscrapers. Maybe it's simply about finding the right line, the one that feels like home when the train doors close.

With love & grit,

Subways, Skylines, and Shark Deals: The Artist's Guide to Record Deals

I couldn't help but wonder, in the ever-changing cityscape of the music industry, are record labels the sharks circling the waters... or the skyscrapers that help us see the skyline from a new height?

For years, the conversation around signing to a label has been polarized. On one block, the "stay independent" crowd preaches freedom, control, and DIY hustle. On another, artists still crave that elusive deal, the one that promises structure, strategy, and access to a bigger stage.

But maybe the real conversation isn't whether labels are good or bad. Maybe it's how we approach them. Because walking into a label meeting is a lot like stepping onto the set of Shark Tank: lights on, cameras rolling, and all eyes on you and your pitch.

Why Record Labels Still Matter

Labels are the skyscrapers of the music city, expensive real estate, but full of resources. They've got the connections, the budget, the marketing muscle, and the kind of global visibility that's hard to achieve on your own. They're not just investors; they're infrastructure.

A good label can turn your single into a statement, your tour into a movement, your vision into a visible brand. They know the streets, the shortcuts, and the skyline views. But they don't just hand over the keys; you have to earn your way in.

The Shark Tank Parallel

Every artist dreams of walking into that meeting where someone across the table says, "We want in." But just like in Shark Tank, the deal isn't made on dreams alone. It's made on leverage.

Think of yourself as the entrepreneur. The product? You. The pitch? Your art, your story, your world.

The sharks, or in this case, the A&Rs and label executives, are listening for proof that your idea works. They want to know your audience, your numbers, your momentum. They're not just buying into your sound, they're buying into your strategy.

Your Bargaining Power Is Everything

In the city, the people who get where they're going know the subway map by heart. In the industry, your map is made of data, direction, and drive.

Ask yourself:

What makes your sound stand out in a crowded skyline?

What's your mission, your "why," your compass?

Who's your demographic, and how do they move through your world?

What need are you solving for them: empowerment, escape, belonging, freedom?

And most importantly, what numbers prove your train is already in motion: streams, followers, engagement, merch sales, ticket sales?

Because when you sit across from a label, it's not about convincing them you're great. It's about showing them you've already built a city worth investing in.

The Win-Win Relationship

Not all sharks bite like Kevin O'Leary. Some partner, some mentor, some push you to grow in ways you couldn't have on your own.

Different Routes, Same City

Know the Terms Before You Sign

In this city, the street signs matter, and in the music industry, so does the fine print. If you're walking into a deal, don't just bring your talent, bring your literacy. Because the biggest difference between a dream and a disaster is usually hidden in the contract clauses.

Here are the essentials every artist should know before shaking hands on a deal:

Advance: the upfront money a label gives you, but it's a loan, not a gift. It's recouped (paid back) from your share of revenue, usually starting with album sales and streaming royalties.

Recoupment: the repayment process. Before you see any profit, your royalties first go toward paying back the advance and any expenses (recording, marketing, tour support, etc.).

Royalty Rate: the percentage you earn after recoupment. The higher your leverage, the better your cut. Typically anywhere from 10% to 22%

Deductions: labels subtract costs for marketing, packaging, piracy, and promotion before paying you. Golden rule: fewer deductions mean more money for you.

Grant of Rights: how the label gains control of your masters. They might license them (temporary) or assign them (permanent). Ideally, negotiate a short license, 3 to 5 years, and always request a reversion (when rights return to you)

Exclusivity: you can't record for another label during the deal term, and sometimes you're even restricted from re-recording your own songs afterward.

Term: how long the deal lasts. Indie deals often cover 1 to 3 albums, major labels 4 to 7 albums (though this is changing as albums are fading out and singles are coming into major play with streaming)

Territory: the geographic area where your label has rights, from one country to worldwide.

Think of these terms like subway stops, miss one and you might end up miles from where you meant to go. Never sign without legal eyes on it. Even the best shark won't bite if you swim with a good lawyer or attorney.

The Takeaway

Maybe it's time to stop seeing record labels as villains and start seeing them as skyscrapers. Tools for height, not handcuffs. In this concrete jungle, there's room for both independence and partnership; it's all about timing, leverage, and knowing the lay of your land.

Recent Posts

Comments